What is Vanity Publishing?
Vanity publishing refers to a publishing model where authors pay a company to publish their books. These companies, known as vanity publishers, typically charge for services such as editing, cover design, formatting, and marketing. Vanity publishers often accept all manuscripts regardless of quality, as their primary revenue comes from authors' fees rather than book sales.
What is Self-Publishing?
Self-publishing is a process where authors independently publish their books, retaining full control over the entire publishing process, including editing, design, distribution, and marketing. Authors can use platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP), IngramSpark, or other self-publishing services to distribute their books. In self-publishing, the author typically bears the upfront costs but keeps all the profits from book sales.
Key Differences Between Vanity Publishing and Self-Publishing
Control and Rights:
Self-Publishing: Authors retain full control over their work, including rights, royalties, and creative decisions.
Vanity Publishing: Authors may relinquish some control over their work, and contracts can sometimes be exploitative, giving the publisher a large share of royalties.
Costs:
Self-Publishing: Authors pay for services like editing, cover design, and marketing, but they choose and manage these services themselves.
Vanity Publishing: Authors pay a significant fee upfront to the publisher for a package of services, which may not always be of high quality.
Quality and Acceptance:
Self-Publishing: The quality of the book is in the hands of the author, who can choose professional services to enhance their book.
Vanity Publishing: These publishers accept all manuscripts, focusing more on collecting fees than on the quality of the books.
Revenue:
Self-Publishing: Authors keep the majority of the profits from book sales, often receiving 70% or more in royalties.
Vanity Publishing: Authors may receive a small percentage of the royalties, with the publisher taking a significant cut.
Is Vanity Publishing Worth It?
Vanity publishing is often considered not worth it due to the high costs and low returns. Authors may end up spending a lot of money without seeing significant sales or receiving professional support. The lack of quality control and marketing efforts from vanity publishers can also hinder an author's success.
Differences Between Self-Publishing and Traditional Publishing
Control:
Self-Publishing: Authors have complete control over the publishing process.
Traditional Publishing: The publisher handles editing, design, distribution, and marketing, often with significant input and control over the final product.
Costs:
Self-Publishing: Authors bear the upfront costs but keep all profits.
Traditional Publishing: The publisher covers the costs of publishing, and the author receives an advance and royalties from sales.
Distribution:
Self-Publishing: Authors manage their distribution channels, often through platforms like Amazon.
Traditional Publishing: The publisher has established distribution networks, getting books into bookstores and other retail outlets.
Revenue:
Self-Publishing: Higher percentage of royalties, typically 70% or more.
Traditional Publishing: Authors receive an advance against royalties and earn 10-15% of the book's sale price after the advance is earned out.
Vanity Publishers to Avoid
Authors should be cautious of publishers that:
Charge high upfront fees.
Guarantee bestseller status.
Have poor reviews or no track record of successful books.
Offer vague contracts with unfavorable terms.
Is Vanity Publishing Bad?
Vanity publishing is often viewed negatively due to its focus on extracting money from authors rather than helping them succeed. It can be considered exploitative, especially for new authors who may not be aware of better alternatives like self-publishing or hybrid publishing.
Vanity Publishers List
While specific names can vary, some notorious vanity publishers include:
AuthorHouse
Xlibris
iUniverse
Trafford Publishing
These companies are often criticized for high fees and poor service quality.
Is Amazon a Vanity Publisher?
No, Amazon is not a vanity publisher. Amazon KDP is a self-publishing platform that allows authors to publish their books for free. Authors retain control over their work and earn royalties from sales without paying upfront fees to Amazon.
Vanity Publishing Costs
The costs associated with vanity publishing can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on the package and services offered. These costs often include editing, cover design, formatting, and basic marketing, but the quality of these services may be subpar.
Best Vanity Publishers
It's generally advised to avoid vanity publishers altogether due to their exploitative nature. Authors should consider reputable self-publishing companies or hybrid publishers that offer better support and value.
Self-Publishing Companies
Reputable self-publishing companies include:
Amazon KDP
IngramSpark
Draft2Digital
Lulu
Smashwords
These platforms offer various tools and services to help authors publish and distribute their books while retaining control and earning a fair share of royalties.
Hybrid vs. Vanity Publishing
Hybrid Publishing:
A blend of traditional and self-publishing.
Authors invest in publishing services but receive professional support and share royalties.
Offers more credibility and quality compared to vanity publishing.
Vanity Publishing:
Authors pay high fees upfront with little professional support.
Focuses on making money from authors rather than book sales.
Often has a poor reputation and questionable business practices.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Understanding the differences between vanity publishing and self-publishing is crucial for authors looking to publish their work. Self-publishing offers greater control, better revenue potential, and higher quality, making it a more favorable option for most authors. Authors should research and choose reputable self-publishing companies or consider hybrid publishing for a balanced approach.
Comments